Readings
Fiction 
Folk and Fairy tales
Horror/Spooky
Appropriate for all ages
Full length text
Click for audiobook
Paradise Lost, by John Milton, 1667 - It's the full text of Paradise Lost. Check out Gustave Dore's beautiful illustrations on archive.org here. 

The Legend of Sleepy Hollow, by Washington Irving, 1819 - Classic colonial American ghost story on the subject of fear and folklore. Warning for racist language/framing (brief). 

Thumbelina, by Hans Christian Andersen, 1849 - Fairy tale. Thumbelina was born into this world a flower, and happiness does not come easily. 

The Happy Prince, by Oscar Wilde, 1888 - Short fairy tale about a Prince and a Sparrow.
The Yellow Wallpaper, by Charlotte Perkins Gilman, 1892 - A woman is confined to the attic of the new home she shares with her husband, "for her own good". Short psychological horror story. 
The Flowering of the Strange Orchid, by H.G. Wells, 1894 - Quick take on "orchidelirium" by one of the original sci fi greats. 
A Rose For Emily, by William Faulkner, 1930 - The life and death of the last heiress of a wealthy Southern legacy. Warning for racist language throughout (appropriate to the setting/time period). 

A Visit, by Shirley Jackson, 1952 - A young woman visits her friend's decadent estate for summer vacation. Short story with surreal mystery elements. Audio Only. 
All Summer in a Day, by Ray Bradbury, 1954 - Sun makes a quick appearance on Venus. Short sci-fi drama story.
Ringing the Changes, by Robert Aickman, 1955 - A poorly-planned honeymoon falls on a strange night in a strange town. Short personal drama ghost story.
The Lady of the House of Love, by Angela Carter, 1975 - Sleeping Beauty by way of Nosferatu; expect the usual hallmarks of vampire fiction. 

The Specialist's Hat, by Kelly Link, 1998 - Two girls move to a strange old house when their father decides to write a history of its original owner, a mostly-forgotten poet. Short ghost story with magical realism and horror elements.
Non-fiction
- Notes on Camp, by Susan Sontag, 1964
- Clowns, by Shirley Jackson, pre-1965 - warning for outdated/historical understandings of gender and culture
- Ways of Seeing, by John Berger, 1972
- The Carrier Bag Theory of Fiction, by Ursula Le Guin, 1986 - warning for implications of biological essentialism
- Understanding Comics, by Scott McCloud, 1993
- Little Red Riding Hood: The Path of Needles or the Path of Pins, by Terri Windling, 1997 - warning for discussions of sexuality and rape
- The Significance of Plot Without Conflict, by Still Eating Oranges collective, 2012